By Faizan Jaleel (Programme Development Manager for Brooke India)
27 Apr 2010
It was horrible to see the fresh firing mark on the donkey. I felt a certain convulsion in my stomach and a lot more grief about the wounds caused by the firing inflicted on this small, docile and pretty donkey. He was unable to move properly, and I could feel the same pain, but was helpless. I immediately asked for the owner of the donkey and resolved to give him a piece of mind, in fact, to be honest the initial thought that crossed my mind was to give him the same wound and ask him “how does that feel mate?”
I was informed that the owner lives in a nearby village and we went there. By the time (it took around an hour to locate the owner and reach him) I reached that donkey owner, my initial thoughts were diluted, but the sense and feeling of immense pain and grief remained. I reached the owner with quite a conviction of intending to have a strong word with him – but as soon as I saw a depleting figure of a malnourished and crumpled old man with a stick to support him – I mellowed down.
On reaching him I asked: “why have you done this to your donkey, don’t you understand the pain that he is in? What if someone puts you through such a treatment?” The answer both startled and shocked me, with tears dropping from his eyes, he explained: “Saheb (Sir), these animals are a source of my livelihood, whatever I do, I do it for their betterment. You have come just a month before and we have been rearing these donkeys for decades and that too without any support. There are no doctors for these animals – Saheb (Sir) there are no doctors even for us here! Give us an alternative and we won’t do it (firing), it’s our helplessness that leads us to do this, not our will.”
I have no words to say and found myself wanting for words.
This is the situation that I have encountered many times in my tenure with Brooke India. I felt happy for the fact that we have started to work in this remote area of Kurnool (a district in the state of Andhra Pradesh, through our partner, Blue Cross of Hyderabad). We hopefully will be able to treat as well as build the capacity of local veterinarians to treat cases, and hope they can help us stop more owners inflicting the immense pain of these harsh traditional methods on their animals. I, and the team working in the area, hope to intensify our efforts in creating awareness among the very poor donkey owners about various management and welfare related issues.
I hope and wish that such a case will never come in sight again, till then we can hope and isn’t it ‘hope’ the thing that helps us stick to our resolve of envisioning a world that’s free of pain and suffering for animals.
Thanks to the Brooke for reaching where no one has reached before – the path less travelled is the path for us and we are satisfied, at the end of the day, that we have reduced some suffering and a little pain from this painful and agonising world for working animals.
Your comments
It is heartbreaking to read this story. This practice 'firing' was prevelent when I lived in the Middle East also and of course used to be used in the UK.
Reminds me of an old 'vegetable man' who used to ride his donkey around the streets of Bahrein in the 70's calling out his wares. although the vegetables were wilted, I always bought some.
One day he stopped and showed me his donkey's grazed knee. I said 'Stanish shwire, M'fadlac, meaning 'wait a minute please' and went to get my canister of 'instant antiseptic spray skin'
Seeing it was superficial,I sprayed the donkey's knee. Then the old man lifted up his 'longei' and showed me his knee, all deformed from arthritis. I am not a doctor and I couldn'thelp him and did not have enough Arabic to expliain.
David Brown How sad that animal owners are forced to do such horrible acts. However, The Brooke not only treats the animals that are sick or injured but they work tirelessly hard to educate the owners on animal welfare and dispelling old wives tales. Bit by bit, they are slowly eliminating their need in the areas that they visit. Let's hope one day The Brooke is not needed but as long as are, I'll be happy to give them whatever I can afford.





Pauline I am an English nurse and have lived in Saudi Arabia for many years and it is sad to see that firing still happens here too where there are vets!!! Education is a must!
Faizan I admire you for the work you are doing, Please please continue as I will continue supporting Brooke till the day I die and doing what I can for horses in this country.





Pauline Taylor I am so glad that there is someone there helping these poor creatures. As soon as I can will send a donation.
When I look at my own shetland pony and what a great life he has compared to the terribly hard life these little donkeys have.
Wish I could be there for them but I know that is not possible, so will try and help in other ways.




